4

A freshwater dip is common practice to treat many parasites as well as a precaution before introducing new fish (especially wild caught).

What's a freshwater dip?
Most marine fish prefer a salinity in the neighborhood of 1.024 ppm. Smaller organisms are more sensitive to this requirement, especially sudden fluctuations; so we take freshwater that has similar parameters in every other regard (namely temperature and pH) and submerse the fish in it for a few minutes. It's harmless to the fish but the other organisms cannot tolerate the hyposalinity.

My Question
If this parameter shock is a viable method for treating marine fish, why is this not the case for freshwater?

2

the reason for not giving freshwater fish a salt water dip is this the salt water is dangerous on a cellular level for the fish due to the change of the osmotic pressure in the cells.

here is a site explaining this in the part about anatomy and physiology http://fishlaboratory.com/fish/freshwater-fish-vs-saltwater-fish

in freshwater fish the level of salt is higher inside the cell than it is in the water surounding the fish so the cells keep the salt innside them.

if you dip the freshwater fish in water containing high level of salt the salt water will pull the water out of the cells of the fish so the fish gets dehydrated and starts to drink water to compensate for the loss of water from the cells but this adds more salt making the fish loose even more water until it dies from dehydration.

saltwater fish have about the same consentration of salt in the cells as it is in the water sorounding the fish.

in a saltwater fish if you put it in freshwater the cells will have higher consentration of salt and the cells will absorb water but the saltwater fish can then simply stop drinking and thereby stop adding dangerous levels of water to the cells.

in saltwater the fish is drinking constantly to flush out the excess salt from its body.

fish that lives part of their life in saltwater and part of their life in freshwater have special adaptations in their gills as this is the organ regulating the water and salt level in the fish,the same goes for fish living in brackish water.

another link http://www.blogionik.org/salt-regulation/

edit:i had the transport of water to and from the cells reversed but this is now corrected.

| improve this answer | |
3

The problem with treating saltwater fish is that the medicines that will kill the microorganisms that are harming the fish will also kill the microorganisms that are helpful to the tank (e.g. the ones living in the sand and corals). So to counteract that, people have resorted to taking the fish out of the tank, and treating it in a quarantine tank, or "dipping" it in treatment.

The only real concern with freshwater tanks, since there isn't a concern for microorganisms, is whether the medicine will harm any invertebrates, or possibly live plants, in the tank. Even if some types of treatments will harm them, the supply and demand for freshwater tank treatments is so high that there are plenty of different treatment methods to choose from.

The closest thing to freshwater "dipping" I think would be aquarium salt. But rather than dipping the fish into it, most people will add it directly into the tank since the average freshwater tank doesn't have anything that would be harmed by a small dose of the salt. So in a sense, there is a "saltwater dip" but there's no point in doing any actually dipping.

| improve this answer | |

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.