I look after two common goldfish in a 56L filtered tank with an airstone for additional aeration. Over the past two days, one of the fish has been appearing to be sick, suffering with what I can only describe as looking like "internal bleeding" around the gills, fins and face.

The description online of ammonia poisoning matches the symptoms, but the tank reading of both ammonia and nitrite (using strip tests) read nil. I also conducted a 50% water change in case of the tests being faulty (they are within the expiry date listed) but have observed no improvement to the physical condition of the fish, and they appear worse today than yesterday. There do not appear to be any behavioural changes, the fish ate as normal yesterday (I am currently withholding food from today, though), does not appear to be hovering around near the top of the tank and does not appear particularly lethargic.

Please would somebody be able to help me diagnose and treat this issue?

ill fish picture 1

ill fish picture 2

ill fish picture 3

1 Answer 1


Too long for a comment but not really a proper answer, so some advice.

I’ve heard of "ammonia spikes" which seems to tally with your story. I’ve had them myself: beautiful fantail, white tail, red lines appeared one morning but all readings were in the safe limits. No other fish affected. The blood streaks didn’t really disappear, either, although the fish lived a reasonably long life and didn’t seem bothered by them ever.

That said, the streaking I had didn’t look anywhere as bad as this (it was limited to a few lines on the huge fantail tail and some on the pectoral fins). Also, going by your photo, your fish look stressed: the dorsal fin is down and the other fins are clamped. It could be that they’re stressing about the camera just at the point of the photo being taken or the water change. But they don’t look happy in the photo, even without the blood streaks.

There’s one other thing it could be. Bacterial infections can cause blood streaking like this but the only time I’ve seen it, it was on the belly and the fish had had dropsy for some time before that. Your fish don’t have dropsy but do look out for it. Dropsy is bad.

Some things to check:

  • Post numbers here for your chemistry. There are some experienced fish keepers on here and posting numbers is usually the first thing requested.
  • Check your pH. I had issues with a decreasing pH (soft water area). Didn’t realise for years and my resident fish seemed to adapt as it crept slowly down. All fixed with a coral gravel buffer.
  • How is the water in your area? Any chance they’re changed the chemistry at the water treatment plant? When was your last water change before this on? Do you have to worry about chloramine?
  • Have you dosed with stress coat?

If it’s all of your fish, it’s likely to be a water issue. Make sure your strips are in date and consider taking a sample of water to your local fish store for them to test. Some fish stores even supply water, too. Make sure there’s nothing gumming up your filter and check your "stock" levels. Goldfish are big and dirty. I have 3 in 180 litre tank and I would not consider more (even though 2 of them are still tiny). Overstocking just makes for more work and I’m lazy. If your fish are still quite small, the 56l tank might be plenty big for now.

If it’s just one of your fish, see if you can see anything else on the fish. Are it’s gills a good colour? I must say I can’t see anything else wrong with it. Is it eating and pooping ok? Keep an eye on the other fish.

Lastly, goldfish do change colour sometimes. One of the photos makes this look bad, but the others not so much. I think it’s unlikely given the actual colour change but not completely impossible.

Good luck!

  • 2
    Hi Pam, thanks so much for your thoughtful response. The other fish in the tank appear unaffected (at least so far). It is eating and pooping okay, the internal colour of the gills looks okay. The fin clamping seems to have gone away since I posted this, thankfully. Will post full chemistry numbers later. My last water change was the week before this issue occurred (was a partial, ~15%, change). I use Tap Safe to try to avoid chlorine/choloramine issues. May 9, 2021 at 17:19
  • 2
    @lila why are there lots of asterisks in your comment?
    – Tim
    May 9, 2021 at 20:45
  • 1
    @ThomasRussell, if the fin clamping is gone, then it might be ok. Your water-from-the-tap sounds good. It sounds like an ammonia spike. My local fish store told me about them - apparently other customers had reported them and tried to investigate them, but I don't have any other information. My experience suggests they're more common in over-stocked tanks (I naively used to over-stock), and more evident in big finned fish.
    – Pam
    May 10, 2021 at 7:24
  • @Pam - I think it may well have been an ammonia spike. The fish has now completely reverted to the original colour and is no longer exhibiting any symptoms. The other fish wasn't affected at any point. Very scary though! Thanks very much for your help! May 17, 2021 at 18:15
  • 1
    Thank you so much for letting us know the fish was ok @ThomasRussell. I couldn’t have predicted it with mine either, so glad my experience could help someone else.
    – Pam
    May 17, 2021 at 21:17

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.