So I've been leaving my dog's toys scattered about; she'll come ask me for fetch or tug by bringing me a toy. I've been recently reading, however, that I shouldn't leave tug ropes out, because she'll chew on them and swallow strings of yarn or whatever it is they're made of and that's bad for her. The thing is, her favorite tug toy is her favorite toy period; she carries it around the house and often asks for tug with it (at least 4-5 times a day). Should I take it away from her and put it up and only get it down for play sessions? She's a shelter dog and I'm trying to give her a sense of security and "home" as well, she was clearly abandoned in a yard before and she hates to be out of my sight.
Should I take my dog's favorite tug-of-war toy away from her to prevent her from potentially eating pieces of it?
10I think that the best and most fair way to solve this question is to group all the people into two opposing teams: those who advise for leaving the toy and those who advise for hiding it, and have these teams play tug-of-war versus one another - the winners get to have their views claimed as the official correct answer.– lilaMar 29, 2021 at 22:06
6@lila: OK, but the teams have to play tug-of-war with their teeth! That's the only fair way... :-)– Bob Jarvis - Слава УкраїніMar 30, 2021 at 20:31
As long as she doesn't destroy the rope, I wouldn't worry.
Traditional rope toys are made of cotton or a comparable natural fiber because they are intended to be chewed on and ingested in small amounts. As long as you only play tug of war or the dog only carries it around, they are no problem.
The problem arises when the dog actually chews through strands of the toy. If a dog tries to swallow big chunks, she could choke or suffocate on them or they could block her small intestine. And long strands could be a problem because they may not pass the digestive system in one go. If one end is stuck in the stomach and the other end already passed into the small intestine, the intestine can be cinched and cut off from blood flow. This is incredibly painful, and can lead to death because the symptoms are often confused and the problem diagnosed too late. The same problem arises if cats try to eat toys on a long string.
2doglab.com/dog-rope-toy/#rope-toy-safety and preventivevet.com/dogs/choosing-safe-dog-chew-toys (scroll down to "ropes") as for her behavior: yes, she actually destroyed one inferior rope toy we bought her. Chewed the tennis ball on it into bits, then chewed the rope where the ball was attached in half. Mar 28, 2021 at 20:35
5Under these conditions, I had to revise my answer. I've honestly never seen a dog chew such a thick rope into strands and assumed they were sturdy enough, but I guess I underestimated the persistence of some dogs. Swallowing strings or strands can actually be a health risk. If she's slow in her progress, cut loose strands away from the toy and replace the whole thing if it becomes unstable. If she manages to destroy it in one session while being alone, she shouldn't have one of those toys at her disposal.– Elmy ♦Mar 29, 2021 at 6:36
4Dogs that chew toys to bits should be kept away from tennis balls, too. We had a dog nearly die from a piece that got caught in her intestine. They don't show up well on x-rays so a vet may not spot it. Luckily our vet found it by touch. Expensive operation later, dog was fine. Mar 30, 2021 at 13:51
Does she actually obviously damage this rope toy? You say in a comment that she destroyed a different rope toy (that had a ball attached), but if she doesn't show any signs of causing damage to this specific rope toy then she's unlikely to wake up one morning and immediately rip it to a dangerous state. You should monitor it for wear over time and be ready to replace it when it starts wearing out--but that's something you should do for all toys anyway.
If she is obviously damaging it to the point where she can wear through it quickly, then yes you should take it away from her when she's unsupervised...but try to find something else that she likes that's safer. Perhaps if she likes the texture of the rope then she would like some of the textured rubber toys (look for teething toys, those have a lot of texture)... Some of the rubber toys are also tug-type toys.
3Good call -- so far she hasn't destroyed any of the more sturdy rope toys so maybe that one was just too weak for her. I just checked her favorite toy and it shows no sign of serious damage, just a few snapped threads, and she chews on it a lot. Mar 30, 2021 at 0:16
I actually disagree with Elmy here. If your dog could swallow a large chunk of the rope, they may choke and die.
To prevent this, I would consider:
getting a tougher toy/rope that your dog won't be able to destroy;
keeping your dog under more supervision;
buying alternative toys so you can take the said toy away when you aren't watching your dog and giving it back when you return while still keeping your dog mentally stimulated and happy;
exercising and playing more with your dog so they won't destroy toys out of boredom.