I'm in the process of downsizing my life. Putting the kid through college and moving into travel trailer living. As a single woman I'd like a dog that is loyal and admittedly a little intimidating for strangers. I plan on spending the majority of the time at whatever national/state forests I can find. I'm very much an adventurous and outdoors type of person. I have confidence in my ability to train a dog. I've had a standard poodle mix, Springer mix and a basset mix in the past. Just curious of opinions to give a lady a little peace of mind and companionship in the woods.

  • Hi Kat and welcome to Pets SE, I added relevant tags.
    – lila
    Nov 5, 2020 at 23:08
  • 1
    Welcome to pets.SE :) You maybe should formulate a short sentence as question, and do not ask for opinions. Opinion based answers are not very welcome here, but it is okay, if someone has a opinion and bring sources for it. Try to find the attributes that are the important for you, and ask which breed is popular for it :) Nov 6, 2020 at 9:07

1 Answer 1


There are several aspects you need to consider, including:


Traditional herding and guard breeds were bred exactly for your purpose: to protect familiar individuals (animals or humans) from potentially dangerous individuals (animals or humans). Different sites offer different lists and classifications of breeds, like the American Kennel Club.

A mixed breed is no worse or less worthy than a pure breed and often has less medical problems.

I'd stay away from "beautiful" overbred dogs like German Shepherds and Boxers. During the last decades, when the breed lost it's original purpose because keeping sheep wasn't profitable anymore and electric fences where cheaper than dogs, the focus of breeders switched from a functional work dog to a "beautiful" fashion dog. This led to numerous medical problems for the poor animals. If you choose a puppy of one of those breeds, look for "old fashion" and archaic body features in their parents.

evolution of German Shepherd Dogs
Image Source


The breed of a dog has great influence but doesn't define the personality of a dog.

Please have a look at this answer which summarizes the Meet your Match dog assessment system. You'll probably want a socially or internally motivated dog with medium energy level (first or second row, orange category). If you follow the link to the system description, you can find a manual how to assess the character of puppies and adult dogs.

Since your dog needs to be socialized very well, I would only consider shelter dogs that have led a similar life before (meeting strangers on a regular basis) and are not aggressive towards people and other dogs.


A big dog may look intimidating, but it doesn't have to be a giant. An agressively barking Akita is surely more intimidating than a docile Great Dane.

Please consider the available space in your trailer. Will the dog be able to move freely? Will it have enough space to stay inside a whole day when it rains?

And will you be able to hold the leash steady if your dog pulls you full power?


There might be some regulations regarding breeds (like fighting dog breeds), taxes and letting dogs run free in an unfenced area. You might not be allowed to bring your dog everywhere, or places might require the dog to be leashed and muzzled at all times.

  • 1
    For the size, maybe the size/weight of the owner should be matched too :) (for emergencies, like carrying the dog, or hold it on a lash) Nov 6, 2020 at 9:09

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.