I have a Labrador retriever that is two and a half years old. He has some odd aggression when he is put in his crate.

90%-95% of the time, he goes in his crate with no abnormalities. He even goes on the command "In your crate".

Every now and then, about 5%-10% of the time, when we put him in his crate, he becomes slightly aggressive. Specifically barking at us and chewing on the crate. He seems to also trigger into this aggressive mode if we drop something (a sock, phone, keys, etc..) near his crate and have to pick it up. Also rubbing the carpet near the crate seems to agitate him into this mode.(Cleaning up the carpet if he has been muddy, etc..)

Upon leaving the room and letting him "calm down" for 10-15 minutes or opening the door and letting him out of his crate he is "back to normal" and shows no aggression.

Is there anything that we could be doing to put him into this mode?

Some other information about him that may be helpful.

  • As he has gotten older we typically have left him out of his crate more. When we leave the house he is typically left out unless we know someone is coming over, we need to clean and have him out of the way, or we are at my parents house where he stays in a crate.

  • We do not feed him in his crate. He was fed in his crate as a puppy but this stopped around 5-6 months.

1 Answer 1


Barking is not always a sign of aggression. First and foremost it's a communication tool.

To understand what your dog is trying to communicate in those "abnormal" instances, you need to interpret the vocal clues and body language.

Vocal language

A dog's barking is almost comparable to a human's shouting.

  • Dogs bark to welcome people that matter to them like humans squee when greeting friends
  • Dogs bark while playing and having fun like children scream in play
  • Dogs bark to warn off intruders and agressors like police officers shout out to people during an operation
  • Many dogs bark if they're insecure or don't know how to act in certain situations. This can escalate to real agression if you harass them, but most dogs try to move away and avoid a conflict rather than attack.

A happy barking is often done in a higher pitch and might be accompanied by whining.
An aggressive barking is often accompanied by visual clues and a gurgling sound.

Body language

The face of a dog tells a lot about whether the bark is agressive or not. Have a look at these examples. Can you tell which dog is agressive?

aggressive bark

non-aggressive bark

The body language of the dog in the first image is aggressive.

  • He's pulling up his lips and wrinkling his nose to display his teeth as much as possible.
  • His ears are pulled back and close to the head.

In the second picture the body language is not aggressive.

  • You can see the lower canines, but the upper canines are hidden behind the lips
  • The ears are pointed forwards, indicating alertness or interest

Your dog's behanvior

Most of what you describe indicates that your dog barks for attention.

Chewing at the crate most likely means that he doesn't want to be in the crate. He wants to interact with people or play and is frustrated at being sent into the crate.

Same thing when you drop an object near his crate. Falling / moving things are always interesting and he probably wants to at least sniff it, maybe even play with it. But he cannot reach it through the crate and barks either because he's frustrated or to prompt you to give it to him.

Cleaning the carpet can trigger a playful bark (because of the movement) or an insecure bark (our dog always barks at the vacuum, but it's not agressive and he wouldn't attack it).

What you should do

Analyze the body language of your dog. If he's actually agressive, you should do regular obedience trainings with him to assert your dominance over him. Under no circumstances should you cause him pain as punishment, because then he might learn to strike first before you can hurt him.

If his barking is not an expression of aggression (which is much more probable), you can choose to give him a toy like a Kong or food dispenser ball or a chewing stick to entertain him. Not every single time, but for example if you put him in the crate while having guests. This is like a consolence: you cannot play with our guests, but have a treat / toy instead.

Otherwise simply ignore his antics. If his barking doesn't yield the desired result, he'll stop soon enough.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.