2

Summer is approaching again. Last summer, I had a lot of trouble keeping the temperature in my aquarium at 30°C. My fish prefer 21-24°C, but I couldn't get it any lower than 30. So I want to avoid having to go through all that trouble again, and to keep the fish happy. I doubt fans are going to help enough, and I don't want to have a refrigerator or an A/C in the room. So I figured an alternative solution which involves passing the water through a heat sink (like the ones on a CPU). Heat sinks are usually made of aluminum. So I was wondering whether running water over aluminum could be harmful.

  • 3
    A lot of people prefer not to use aluminum, as it can rust and when exposed to water is deadly to fish. – Ginge Jun 18 at 19:47
  • I would try to acquire plastic tubing or something along those lines – Ginge Jun 18 at 19:48
2

Aluminum is bad in saltwater tanks which I'm assuming is what you're running because freshwater tanks are generally fine at 30C.

I honestly don't recommend any metal in the tank or a component in contact with the water unless it's titanium. Aluminum gets degraded fairly quickly and even metals that are more suitable for saltwater such as bronze have high levels of copper in them which are not good for aquariums.

Additionally, CPU cooling systems are not designed to cool components to a super low level unless you're talking about active cooling systems. They work great for computers but computers don't need ~30C operating temperatures. And, even with an exceptionally designed heatsink, you're still at the mercy of ambient temperature, and the closer you get to it, the less efficient the heatsink will be.

Short of using an active cooling system like a chiller or cooling down the room that the tank is in, evaporative cooling in a low humidity environment is going to be the best and cheapest way to get the tank's temperature down if that applies to you. If it doesn't I would be looking at cooling the fish tank room, a chiller, or a peltier based cooling device if it's a small tank.

  • You make very good points. I was looking forward to building a nice piece of tech, but I guess I need a rethink. Thanks. – HoneyBadger Jun 18 at 22:11
1

Depending on the fish 30 C is generally OK , if they have air/oxygen. The higher temperatures reduce the solubility of gasses in water, in particular oxygen. So an aerator and/or a filter that moves the surface water ,such as a H O B type, is good and should be enough. A small fan blowing on the surface could help . I have a tank on the deck ,in full shade, that gets over 32 C , but it only has anabantids ( paradise fish) air breathers like bettas. Otherwise , I have many variety s of tropical fish that get at least to 30 C.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.