4

I couldn't find anything online so I'm asking the question here.

I use distilled water for some species of crabs which should have a carbonate hardness of 0.

Now I want to add plants to the aquarium and therefore CO2.

I know there is a table for KH-CO2-pH but it only goes to 0.1 KH while my water should have KH 0.

How will CO2 injection affect pH? I'm looking for the specific numbers. greetings

  • 2
    adding co2 to water without any buffer effect will make pure carbonic acid.using destilled water in a fish tank is crazy in my opinion. – trond hansen Mar 2 '18 at 17:34
4

It sounds as though you already have a good knowledge of how water chemistry works.

In basic terms, KH (carbonate hardness) affects how much the pH can change within the water. The presence of the carbonic acid in the water stops the pH from fluctuating wildly when it is influenced by CO2 or by other pH influencers.

You'll probably be familiar with the classic advice given when attempting to alter your pH: Chances are, you will need to lower your KH so that the changes to the pH have more impact on the actual pH of the tank.

If your KH is 0 that means your pH can be very easily influenced by any factors that would affect your pH. In reference directly to CO2 check out this picture from practical fish keeping:

CO<sub>2</sub> Vs KH Vs pH

You'll see that the mg of CO2 per litre that you need for the pH to fall to 6 at a KH of 0.5 is only 15mg compared to the 87mg you might need for the same pH at a KH of 3.0.

'Okay fine, but what's the answer to my question?'

Injecting a small amount of CO2 into your water will have a big affect on the pH due to the low KH. This may not actually be a problem if you have very limited sources of pH influencers but there is a risk.

I don't know about crabs, but generally very low KH levels are not advised with fish because the pH can swing wildly as a result of pH influences. These can be substrate, decorations and many others. If your environment is very stable (free from potential pH altering sources) carefully injecting CO2 may be feasible for you but low KH and CO2 injection always make me a little nervous.

| improve this answer | |
0

Distilled water and CO2 will kill fish and I expect crabs. I have more or less done it twice by accident. I would never use distilled but our tap water has fairly low mineral content : I put water in an empty aquarium ( no gravel, rocks or plants) for several hours while working on their home tank . A few hours later most were dead , pH tested below 6.2

| improve this answer | |

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.