So my wife and I set ourselves to training our cat to use the toilet. Over the course of several months, we performed the following steps and were met with great success.
- We moved the covered litter box close to the toilet.
- We switched the litter out for a soluble brand so it wouldn't wreck our plumbing.
- We raised the litter box to the level of the toilet.
- We removed the top of the covered litter box.
- We moved it on top of the toilet.
- My wife then molded an aluminum turkey pan to fit inside the bowl of the toilet and filled it with the soluble litter.
- We cut a small hole in the center of the turkey pan.
- Over time, we gradually expanded the size of the hole until there was nothing left for our kitty to stand on but the toilet seat.
Now, all that exists is the shining rim of the turkey pan below the toilet seat.
Our cat has been successfully peeing and pooping in the toilet for about 3 months or so now. That is until this last Christmas. When we put our tree up, it created a nice, little, isolated corner in our apartment. One day I discovered a poop in the corner. Since then, there have been a handful of incidents where she'll poop in the same corner if it's not covered with stuff, or like this morning, she'll poop right in front of the toilet on the mat. It doesn't happen every time, or even half the time, but just every now and then.
I have a hunch that our cat doesn't particularly like the sensation of pooping on the toilet because it splashes up onto her butt. Things that I've read say that if a cat doesn't like their pooping space, they'll pick a different spot. I know there are people who have had complete success with toilet training.
At this point, we're determined to have her using the toilet, so going back to a litter box isn't really an option. Has anyone else had this same problem? And how would you recommend addressing it?
I have considered using toilet paper to cover the surface of the water. This has proven... from experience... to reduce/eliminate splash entirely, but I don't think it will stay there all day, and I don't think I could train her to put toilet paper over the surface of the water.
This really comes down to whether or not this is just something behavioral that needs extra training/addressing in some other manner, or if there's something creative that can be done to improve her experience.