I am missing a small White Cloud Mountain minnow in my newly set 20 gallon (76 L) tank. I just added it and 4 others to the tank less than a week ago. Now, I can only find 7 out of the 8 White Cloud Mountain minnows. Should I seek for it, moving all the plants and decorations?

I was planning not to change water for one more week. Also, the Ludwigia plants in the tank are dying. All the other fish (2 small female betas and 3 Cory cats) are doing well.

What should I do? I think the little White Cloud Mountain minnow may have died - should I move everything to look for it?

Please help!

1 Answer 1


Tank health

Get a pH and ammonia test kit at the very least so that you can monitor your tank's health. Remember to do your weekly water changes. When you first start out a tank it seems very hard, but as time goes by you get used to it and learn how to handle situations.

Fish inches

The general rule of thumb is 1 inch of fish per gallon of water. If you have 8 white clouds, that's 12" of fish (they are 1.5" long) - you said you have 4 other fish, too, so provided they are also little fish, you should be just fine.

Missing White Cloud Mountain minnow

It sounds like you've already looked a little; there's no need to tear the tank up looking for a fish that's probably dead. Watch the area around the tank for anything that smells (perhaps the fish jumped out and died). But the most likely thing is that he died and his corpse is somewhere in the tank. It will turn up eventually, it probably got lost in the plant or in decorations. Wait for it to turn up, and in the meantime watch your pH and ammonia levels carefully (the rotting corpse will hurt the water quality); do extra water changes to keep the ammonia levels low if you need to.


I had a lot of trouble even with the hardiest of live plants, and came to the conclusion that to grow them, you really have to understand the tank cycle, how the plants work, and be in-tune with the different chemicals and additives the plants need to grow (perhaps even a different type of lightblub). There can also be issues with the water you're using, too. The best advice I can give is to do lots of reading and research on planted aquariums, buy the additional chemical tests you will need, and plan out what your tank needs for plants to thrive.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.