Take the 2-minute tour ×
Pets Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for pet owners, caretakers, breeders, veterinarians, and trainers. It's 100% free, no registration required.

I found this question on an amphibians forum. The answers provided on there were contradictory and I was hoping we could do better here on Pets.SE.

I have had my first axolotl for four months now. She lives in a tank on her own at the moment, but I was hoping to get her a friend. I'd like to get a second axolotl and a pleco. Would these three animals be compatible to keep together? What environment variables should I take into account when considering introducing multiple animals in the same aquarium? Her tank is 18°C, 96 litre, 3 foot.

share|improve this question
    
I'm guessing you mean the common pleco? There are about a half-dozen different species of pleco that you commonly see in the pet trade, and some are probably be more compatible with others. I could also imagine someone keeping an axolotl might keep some of the more exotic plecos as well -- there are a few hundred species. –  toxotes Feb 5 at 15:01

1 Answer 1

up vote 5 down vote accepted

There are several problems I can see with putting an Axolotl and a Pleco together.

Space. Axolotls generally get to be about 12-14 inches in length, while common plecos will get to be about 2 feet long when they're fully grown. A common pleco itself needs a minimum of a 40 gallon(about 150 litre) aquarium.

Temperature. Axolotls are naturally from coldwater streams/lakes, while freshwater fish kept as pets are generally from warm/tropical streams/lakes. The temperature range for axolotls is about 60-65°F (16°C-18°C), while the temperature range for plecos is about 72°F-82°F (23°C-28°C).

Ideally, you could find a coldwater fish and keep them with the axolotl, but the main problem with keeping things with axolotls is that they try to eat everything. I know some people who will feed guppies to their axolotls. So my worry is that if the pleco isn't the same size as the axolotl to start with (which will also cost around $50-$100), that the axolotl will try to eat it. Plecos have bones in their fins that would catch in the axolotl's throat.

Here's an aggregated list of disasters involving people mixing species. One of which is a pleco and an axolotl. These are the worst case scenarios, but it's all there to show that these things do happen.

Which brings up my next worry, that plecos are notorious for chewing on everything. They commonly suck the slime coating off of other fish, causing them to get sick. I'd be worried about other fish as well, I'd be willing to bet any fish would nibble at the axolotl's gills.

All in all, the best companion for an axolotl is another axolotl. I don't think the risk of the axolotl choking on a fish, or a fish chewing on the axolotl's gills, is worth any perceived friendship.

That being said, I know people who keep apple snails in their axolotl tanks to take care of the algae, but that is because the snails can be big enough that the axolotl's can't eat them. You have to get one that's as big as the axolotl's head, or you'll be pulling it out of it's mouth later.

I have heard that ghost shrimp are ignored by axolotl's pretty regularly, so if you're looking to have something in your tank other than axolotls, that would be my suggestion. Worst case scenario is that they get eaten.


Axolotls Housing

Axolotls Water Requirements

share|improve this answer
    
You have to get one that's as big as the axolotl's head, or you'll be pulling it out of it's mouth later. Yes - there is a mention on the very "disaster list" that you linked of an axolotl trying to eat a snail and having it get stuck :/ (5th image) –  starsplusplus Feb 5 at 15:49
    
This is a well-written answer and I'll link the original poster to it. I'll leave it a few days before accepting in the hope of getting some more opinions from other experts (never hurts to encourage a higher answer ratio). Thanks! –  starsplusplus Feb 5 at 15:51

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.